John Smith, The Girl Chewing Gum (1976)
The Girl Chewing Gum is a 16mm black and white film by British artist John Smith, set on the cross section of Kingsland Road and Stamford Road in Dalston, London Borough of Hackney in 1976.
The voice over the moving image suggests there is a story to tell, as though actors are following directions around a set and therefore moving towards a common cause – that of narrative. However, as we watch the film, we soon become aware of the director’s lack of authority and control over the people, vehicles, objects that move in, through and out of the frame.
If there is a narrative, it is the narrative of the everyday which, it could be argued, has no narrative at all. Initially, the male voice directs the action but there is a shift when we realise the voice is directed by the action. The voice asserts a god-like omniscience as he creates the world in his own image. But he fails. This is important to expose the nature of narrative that imposes order to structure the world, represented here by a street in Hackney. But the street is disordered and structurally unstable. This affects an uncanny feeling as we realise that the action (the moving image) is out of control and, at the same time, we realise an illusion of narrative voice being imposed.
Smith takes the issue of representation one step further. The image is reality but the voice is narrative. It is usual in film for the action to be directed by the word of the script but here, in The Girl Chewing Gum, word is directed by action, as I have said. To take it further, Smith the director talks before the action occurs in order to create the illusion. Therefore, we realise that he has already watched the footage, probably many times. Cracks begin to show through the course of the film. About half way through, the directions do not match the action. The action begins to run away from control. Smith exposes what is otherwise hidden in film to create an absolute, total representation where there are no slips or fissures in the story. In popular film, noticing a continuity error is often the only way to realise its fabrication.
Smith accentuates this towards the end, playing with sound and scene in order to deconstruct a sense of reality. He shows how easily word and image can be manipulated, and how seamlessly we subscribe to false representations. The title emphasises this as ‘the girl chewing gum’ holds no more significance than ‘the woman holding the bag under her arm’ or ‘the man in the boiler suit’. We pay more attention to the girl chewing gum because of the title. We look to her for meaning but the wait is in vain. The only meaning to be found is the deconstruction of meaning; the stripping back of an image that calls itself reality.
We have to keep coming back to the realisation that The Girl Chewing Gum is more complex because the image is reality, showing fragments of real life in Dalston in 1976. The film is a document in the archive, it preserves the past through moving image (in black and white as a result of camera technology at the time). These factors alter our impressions and associations with the past.